I Didn’t Do It!

I watched the first episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation today. Other than being a trip down nostalgia lane, it was thought provoking. The villain in the story, “Q”, lost no time in putting humanity on trial. He demanded that the crew of the Enterprise answer for the actions of humanity committed throughout history. Picard’s reply was, “Test us. We are not the same as them.”

Although we all want to be part of a group and have friends, in the end we don’t want to be lumped together and judged. Do you feel that you need to answer for everyone else’s actions?

The actions of humanity haven’t always been commendable throughout history: War, genocide, rape, murder, terrorism, creating the TV show Family Matters. However, humanity on trial isn’t feasible. None of us are the same. Each of us react different and have distinct moral standards. There are many folks that murder and many folks who render first aid. Movies like Surrogates and Gamer suggest that man will devolve into his basest instincts and drives if there are no consequences for his actions. An example of this is porn. Porn is a kind of surrogacy. You can’t have sex at that moment so someone else is doing it for you. The porn industry does bring in billions of dollars so it is safe to say many people are filling a void with digital pixels of sexual images. Does this mean that people will always choose basic instincts if no consequences are involved?

I won’t deny that giving in to those drives are appealing. However, if you give yourself over to them you may find that you become a slave. (In the voice of Yoda) Nothing more than a beast you may become.

Being human is more than giving in to an inner drive. We have an ability that other creatures do not have. The ability to choose. We have the ability to do good and evil, but that doesn’t mean we automatically choose evil. So, although Nero may have done terrible things, I didn’t. I chose a different path.

Let us all be judged on our own merits. (That is, if we’re ever judged by “Q”.)


6 thoughts on “I Didn’t Do It!

  1. I’ve always liked “Q.” I don’t know what that says about me.

    It would make sense for us to be judged by each others actions if we were the Borg.

  2. I absolutely adore this post. Have you ever read Theology of the Body by Christopher West? It’s all based upon Pope John Paul II’s encyclical and is so very interesting. It helped open my eyes in so many ways. I think you’ll find it intriguing as well.

  3. I watched that episode just a few weeks ago. What struck me about it was the fact that Q had an absolute moral standard by which he judged humanity. And it was a standard which Picard acknowledged at least in part. Murder is wrong. Injustice is wrong. etc. etc.

    Where did this morality spring from? How is it that Q and Picard speak the same moral language? It almost seems like they’re reading from the same law written in their hearts.

    Suggested Reading: Mere Christianity by C.S. Lewis.

  4. Even more interesting when we think that the writers who created him seem to accept as a given that the moral law is so universal that an all-powerful alien being would not only honor it but seek to enforce it on others.

  5. I’m proud of myself for having read this post at all, considering the huge Star Trek picture at the top!
    The ability to make decisions and not just follow our instincts is one of the main things (other than aposable thumbs) that make us distinct from the animals. God made us with a free will; we make choices, good or bad. And there are consequences to all of our choices, whether those are immediate consequences or future ones is irrelevant.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s